How Can We Help?
The Cost of Silence (Letter 30)
Dear Hoptoi,
Something happened recently at an open play that has me wondering what responsibility we have when we see another player doing something we believe is dishonest.
During a game, I noticed a player doing something that appeared to give them an unfair advantage. Another player at the table noticed it too. Neither of us said anything at the time. I think we were both so surprised that we weren’t quite sure what to do, and neither of us wanted to make an accusation if we had misunderstood what we saw.
Afterward, we talked about it with a few other players and learned that others had noticed questionable behavior from the same person on previous occasions. Now people are watching this player closely, some don’t want to play with them, and there’s a lot of conversation happening behind the scenes.
Looking back, I wonder whether our silence at the table actually made things worse. If you witness something you believe may be cheating or collusion, should you say something in the moment? And how do you address it without making an accusation you may not be able to prove?
Silent Witness
Dear Silent Witness,
There’s an important difference between addressing something you witnessed and accusing someone of cheating.
When something questionable happens at the table, silence can feel like the safest response. You may be surprised by what you saw, uncertain whether you understood it correctly, or reluctant to accuse someone of something as serious as cheating. But when you say nothing, you may lose the chance to clarify what happened. Later, observations can become suspicions, suspicions can become conclusions, and before long the conversation shifts from what someone did to what others believe they are.
So what should happen instead?
If You’re a Player
If you see something that doesn’t seem right, the best time to address it is while it is happening. You don’t have to know why the player did it, and you don’t have to call it cheating. Simply pause play and address what you actually observed: “Wait a minute. I saw you move that tile from your rack. Can we clarify what just happened?” If a rule or procedure is involved, resolve it before play continues.
That gives everyone an opportunity to clarify what happened while the details are still fresh. There may be an innocent explanation. There may have been a misunderstanding of the rules. Or you may have witnessed something that genuinely crosses the line. Whatever the explanation, addressing the action is far more constructive than trying to determine someone’s intent after the fact.
If you’re uncomfortable addressing it yourself, or the situation can’t be resolved appropriately at the table, bring the concern privately to the person responsible for the group or event. Tell them what you personally observed, not what you think the other player intended, and allow them to take it from there.
If You’re the Leader or Official
If a concern is brought to you after the fact, take it seriously without immediately treating the allegation as established fact. Ask each person involved to describe privately what they personally observed—not what they heard from someone else or what they believe the other player intended.
One report may leave you with very little to go on. Several people independently describing the same behavior, particularly if it occurred more than once, presents a very different situation. At that point, I believe a private conversation with the player is warranted.
Tell them what has been reported, as factually and neutrally as possible, and give them an opportunity to respond. Listen carefully, but don’t base your decision solely on whether they react with indignation, denial, remorse, or an apology. Consider their response alongside the information you have gathered.
If you conclude the behavior occurred, the next question is whether you can restore trust. If the player acknowledges what they did, takes responsibility, and genuinely wants to make things right, there may be a path forward. That might include acknowledging the behavior to those affected, apologizing, agreeing to the group’s conduct expectations, and understanding that rebuilding trust will take time.
However, not every situation can be repaired. Other players cannot be required to trust someone again, and an apology does not automatically erase the consequences of what happened. The leader ultimately has a responsibility not only to the individual involved, but also to the group’s health and integrity.
Accountability and grace don’t have to be opposites. Sometimes good leadership means leaving room for someone to make things right. It also means recognizing when protecting the group requires letting someone go.
